Trusted by 16 Champions & Europa League clubs, plus 200 more. View Pricing

Under 23 · Bundesliga · 2022-23

Best U23 Young Players in the Bundesliga

182 players aged 23 or under · ranked by Analytical Strength Index

Best Young Players in the Bundesliga (Jul 2026)

Ranked by Analytical Strength Index

Use the search bar below to find specific players, or apply filters to narrow results by club, age range, or market value. Click the chart icon next to any player to view their historical value trajectory and forecast.

🔍
Age: 18–40
€0M–€200M
Showing 179 of 182

Player Rankings

Ranked by Analytical Strength Index. Click any player to view full profile, or click the chart icon to see value history.

#1

Jamal Musiala

Bayern Munich23 years old

112.4M

130.0M

+15.6%

126.0M163.7M

Expected: €144.9M

95.5

#2

Xavi Simons

RB Leipzig23 years old

69.2M

80.0M

+15.6%

77.6M100.7M

Expected: €89.1M

94.6

#3

Aleksandar Pavlovic

Bayern Munich22 years old

56.2M

65.0M

+15.6%

62.3M80.9M

Expected: €71.6M

91.8

#4

Lennart Karl

Bayern Munich18 years old

51.9M

60.0M

+15.6%

65.6M88.6M

Expected: €77.1M

88.4

#5

Castello Lukeba

RB Leipzig23 years old

38.9M

45.0M

+15.6%

44.6M54.5M

Expected: €49.6M

88.4

#6

Jarell Quansah

Bayer 04 Leverkusen23 years old

34.6M

40.0M

+15.6%

39.7M48.5M

Expected: €44.1M

86.9

#7

Can Uzun

Eintracht Frankfurt20 years old

38.9M

45.0M

+15.6%

45.7M61.7M

Expected: €53.7M

85.9

#8

Hugo Larsson

Eintracht Frankfurt22 years old

34.6M

40.0M

+15.6%

38.3M49.8M

Expected: €44.1M

85.6

#9

Tom Bischof

Bayern Munich21 years old

34.6M

40.0M

+15.6%

39.0M52.8M

Expected: €45.9M

85.2

#10

Nathaniel Brown

Eintracht Frankfurt23 years old

30.3M

35.0M

+15.6%

34.7M42.4M

Expected: €38.6M

85.2

#11

Yan Diomande

RB Leipzig19 years old

38.9M

45.0M

+15.6%

44.2M67.3M

Expected: €55.8M

84.1

#12

Antonio Nusa

RB Leipzig21 years old

27.7M

32.0M

+15.6%

29.1M44.3M

Expected: €36.7M

81.8

#13

Bilal El Khannouss

VfB Stuttgart22 years old

25.9M

30.0M

+15.6%

27.6M35.9M

Expected: €31.8M

78.5

#14

Maximilian Beier

Borussia Dortmund23 years old

25.9M

30.0M

+15.6%

27.4M39.4M

Expected: €33.4M

78.4

#15

Brajan Gruda

RB Leipzig22 years old

24.2M

28.0M

+15.6%

25.8M33.5M

Expected: €29.6M

77.6

#16

Johan Manzambi

SC Freiburg20 years old

25.9M

30.0M

+15.6%

29.3M39.5M

Expected: €34.4M

77.2

#17

Konstantinos Koulierakis

VfL Wolfsburg22 years old

21.6M

25.0M

+15.6%

24.8M30.3M

Expected: €27.6M

76.9

#18

Johan Bakayoko

RB Leipzig23 years old

21.6M

25.0M

+15.6%

22.8M32.9M

Expected: €27.9M

76.2

#19

Carney Chukwuemeka

Borussia Dortmund22 years old

21.6M

25.0M

+15.6%

23.0M29.9M

Expected: €26.5M

76.2

#20

Finn Jeltsch

VfB Stuttgart20 years old

21.6M

25.0M

+15.6%

26.3M33.2M

Expected: €29.8M

76.0

...
Showing 1-20 of 179

If you were Bundesliga's sporting director, who would you sign?

Pick a club, select up to 3 players, and build your transfer proposal.

Market Intelligence

Explore Market Size by Position in Bundesliga

Interactive bubble chart showing predicted 2-year growth vs current age for all Bundesliga Young Players. Identify undervalued assets and track market momentum across 23 clubs with €1.5B combined value.

179
Players Tracked

Age Distribution: Bundesliga Young Players

The Bundesliga ALL market shows 2 distinct age segments, with the largest cohort in the 21-23 bracket (139 players, 78% of market). The 21-23 age group holds the most value at €1.1B, averaging €8.1M per player.

U21 years40 players (22%)
384.1MAvg: €9.6M
Top player: Lennart Karl (€60.0M)
21-23 years139 players (78%)
1.1BAvg: €8.1M
Top player: Jamal Musiala (€130.0M)

Top Young Players by Age Bracket

U21 Years (40 players)

1. Lennart Karl(18yo)
60.0M
2. Can Uzun(20yo)
45.0M
3. Yan Diomande(19yo)
45.0M
4. Johan Manzambi(20yo)
30.0M
5. Finn Jeltsch(20yo)
25.0M

21-23 Years (139 players)

1. Jamal Musiala(23yo)
130.0M
2. Xavi Simons(23yo)
80.0M
3. Aleksandar Pavlovic(22yo)
65.0M
4. Castello Lukeba(23yo)
45.0M
5. Jarell Quansah(23yo)
40.0M

Market Value Distribution

Elite Tier Concentration

54%of market value

The top 18 Young Players (10% of players) control €825.0M

1. Jamal Musiala130.0M
2. Xavi Simons80.0M
3. Aleksandar Pavlovic65.0M
4. Lennart Karl60.0M
5. Castello Lukeba45.0M

Market Tiers

Elite (€50M+)4 players (2%)
335.0M
Premium (€30-50M)11 players (6%)
412.0M
High (€15-30M)19 players (11%)
400.0M
Mid (€5-15M)33 players (18%)
254.0M
Emerging (<€5M)112 players (63%)
115.1M

Market structure shows distributed value with elite (€50m+) tier representing 2% of the Bundesliga ALL pool.

Elite (€50M+)

1. Jamal Musiala
Bayern Munich130.0M
2. Xavi Simons
RB Leipzig80.0M
3. Aleksandar Pavlovic
Bayern Munich65.0M
4. Lennart Karl
Bayern Munich60.0M

Premium (€30-50M)

1. Castello Lukeba
RB Leipzig45.0M
2. Jarell Quansah
Bayer 04 Leverkusen40.0M
3. Can Uzun
Eintracht Frankfurt45.0M
4. Hugo Larsson
Eintracht Frankfurt40.0M
5. Tom Bischof
Bayern Munich40.0M

High (€15-30M)

1. Brajan Gruda
RB Leipzig28.0M
2. Konstantinos Koulierakis
VfL Wolfsburg25.0M
3. Johan Bakayoko
RB Leipzig25.0M
4. Carney Chukwuemeka
Borussia Dortmund25.0M
5. Finn Jeltsch
VfB Stuttgart25.0M

Club Distribution: Bundesliga Young Players

Among 23 Bundesliga clubs, RB Leipzig leads with 11 Young Players worth €318.5M (averaging €29.0M per player). The top 10 clubs account for 69% of tracked Young Players.

#1
RB Leipzig
11 players • €318.5M
#2
Bayern Munich
14 players • €310.8M
#3
Eintracht Frankfurt
19 players • €201.1M
#4
Borussia Dortmund
15 players • €123.1M
#5
VfB Stuttgart
15 players • €107.1M
#6
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
10 players • €102.9M
#7
SC Freiburg
9 players • €49.6M
#8
TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
15 players • €46.1M
#9
VfL Wolfsburg
8 players • €41.4M
#10
SV Werder Bremen
7 players • €41.1M

RB Leipzig (11 Young Players)

Xavi Simons(23yo)
80.0M
Castello Lukeba(23yo)
45.0M
Yan Diomande(19yo)
45.0M
Antonio Nusa(21yo)
32.0M
Brajan Gruda(22yo)
28.0M

Bayern Munich (14 Young Players)

Jamal Musiala(23yo)
130.0M
Aleksandar Pavlovic(22yo)
65.0M
Lennart Karl(18yo)
60.0M
Tom Bischof(21yo)
40.0M
Noel Aseko(20yo)
6.0M

Eintracht Frankfurt (19 Young Players)

Can Uzun(20yo)
45.0M
Hugo Larsson(22yo)
40.0M
Nathaniel Brown(23yo)
35.0M
Jean-Mattéo Bahoya(21yo)
25.0M
Farès Chaïbi(23yo)
15.0M

Borussia Dortmund (15 Young Players)

Maximilian Beier(23yo)
30.0M
Carney Chukwuemeka(22yo)
25.0M
Jobe Bellingham(20yo)
25.0M
Aarón Anselmino(21yo)
12.0M
Julien Duranville(20yo)
7.5M

Scout Tools

Advanced analytics for scouting and recruitment decisions. Each tool provides unique insights into player value, potential, and market dynamics.

Pre-Peak Value Efficiency (PPVE)

Identifies pre-peak players offering exceptional value relative to their age bracket. Higher PPVE = better value.

Understanding Pre-Peak Value Efficiency (PPVE)

Bayern Munich's Jamal Musiala at 23 years old has the highest Pre-Peak Value Efficiency at 108.33×. That means Jamal Musiala is valued 108.33× higher than the median player in the 21-23 age bracket-representing exceptional value before reaching peak age.

In second is RB Leipzig's Xavi Simons, who is 23 years old, with a 66.67× PPVE. Third is Aleksandar Pavlovic of Bayern Munich, who is 22 years old with a 54.17× PPVE.

How PPVE is calculated: PPVE compares a player's current market value to the median value of all players in their age bracket. A PPVE of 108.33× means the player is worth 10733% more than typical players their age-making them high-value targets before they reach peak value.

PPVE by Age Bracket

Jamal MusialaBayern Munich
21-23 • 23yo108.33×
€130.0M • 10733% above median
Xavi SimonsRB Leipzig
21-23 • 23yo66.67×
€80.0M • 6567% above median
Aleksandar PavlovicBayern Munich
21-23 • 22yo54.17×
€65.0M • 5317% above median
Castello LukebaRB Leipzig
21-23 • 23yo37.50×
€45.0M • 3650% above median
Jarell QuansahBayer 04 Leverkusen
21-23 • 23yo33.33×
€40.0M • 3233% above median
Tom BischofBayern Munich
21-23 • 21yo33.33×
€40.0M • 3233% above median
Hugo LarssonEintracht Frankfurt
21-23 • 22yo33.33×
€40.0M • 3233% above median
Nathaniel BrownEintracht Frankfurt
21-23 • 23yo29.17×
€35.0M • 2817% above median
Antonio NusaRB Leipzig
21-23 • 21yo26.67×
€32.0M • 2567% above median
Maximilian BeierBorussia Dortmund
21-23 • 23yo25.00×
€30.0M • 2400% above median
Bilal El KhannoussVfB Stuttgart
21-23 • 22yo25.00×
€30.0M • 2400% above median
Brajan GrudaRB Leipzig
21-23 • 22yo23.33×
€28.0M • 2233% above median
Johan BakayokoRB Leipzig
21-23 • 23yo20.83×
€25.0M • 1983% above median
Carney ChukwuemekaBorussia Dortmund
21-23 • 22yo20.83×
€25.0M • 1983% above median
Konstantinos KoulierakisVfL Wolfsburg
21-23 • 22yo20.83×
€25.0M • 1983% above median
RankPlayerAgeBracketCurrent ValueBracket MedianPPVE
#1
Jamal Musiala
Bayern Munich
2321-23130.0M1.2M108.33×
#2
Xavi Simons
RB Leipzig
2321-2380.0M1.2M66.67×
#3
Aleksandar Pavlovic
Bayern Munich
2221-2365.0M1.2M54.17×
#4
Castello Lukeba
RB Leipzig
2321-2345.0M1.2M37.50×
#5
Jarell Quansah
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
2321-2340.0M1.2M33.33×
#6
Tom Bischof
Bayern Munich
2121-2340.0M1.2M33.33×
#7
Hugo Larsson
Eintracht Frankfurt
2221-2340.0M1.2M33.33×
#8
Nathaniel Brown
Eintracht Frankfurt
2321-2335.0M1.2M29.17×
#9
Antonio Nusa
RB Leipzig
2121-2332.0M1.2M26.67×
#10
Maximilian Beier
Borussia Dortmund
2321-2330.0M1.2M25.00×
#11
Bilal El Khannouss
VfB Stuttgart
2221-2330.0M1.2M25.00×
#12
Brajan Gruda
RB Leipzig
2221-2328.0M1.2M23.33×
#13
Johan Bakayoko
RB Leipzig
2321-2325.0M1.2M20.83×
#14
Carney Chukwuemeka
Borussia Dortmund
2221-2325.0M1.2M20.83×
#15
Konstantinos Koulierakis
VfL Wolfsburg
2221-2325.0M1.2M20.83×
#16
Jean-Mattéo Bahoya
Eintracht Frankfurt
2121-2325.0M1.2M20.83×
#17
Conrad Harder
RB Leipzig
2121-2324.0M1.2M20.00×
#18
Eliesse Ben Seghir
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
2121-2324.0M1.2M20.00×
#19
Lennart Karl
Bayern Munich
18U2160.0M4.0M15.00×
#20
Paul Nebel
1.FSV Mainz 05
2321-2318.0M1.2M15.00×

Return-to-Peak Potential (RPP)

Recovery potential from current value to forecasted peak. Shows how much upside remains for players approaching their prime.

Understanding Return-to-Peak Potential (RPP)

Bayer 04 Leverkusen's Axel Tape at 18 years old has the highest Return-to-Peak Potential at +48%. That means Axel Tape is projected to appreciate 48% as they reach their peak age in 8 years-representing significant upside before entering their prime.

In second is VfB Stuttgart's Dennis Seimen, who is 20 years old, with a +48% RPP (6 years to peak). Third is Tiago Pereira Cardoso of Borussia Mönchengladbach, who is 20 years old with a +48% RPP (6 years to peak).

How RPP is calculated: RPP compares a player's current market value to their forecasted peak value, calculating the percentage appreciation potential. A 48% RPP means the player is expected to gain 48% value as they enter their prime-making them excellent growth investments.

Recovery Potential by Player

Axel TapeBayer 04 Leverkusen
8yr to peak+48%
8.0M15.4M
Dennis SeimenVfB Stuttgart
6yr to peak+48%
7.0M13.5M
Tiago Pereira CardosoBorussia Mönchengladbach
6yr to peak+48%
1.5M2.9M
Max SchmittBayern Munich
6yr to peak+48%
500K961K
Lennart KarlBayern Munich
8yr to peak+44%
60.0M107.2M
Luca ErleinTSG 1899 Hoffenheim
7yr to peak+44%
1.3M2.3M
Kacper KoscierskiVfL Bochum
7yr to peak+44%
700K1.3M
Noahkai BanksFC Augsburg
7yr to peak+44%
15.0M26.8M
Jaaso JantunenSC Freiburg
5yr to peak+44%
400K715K
Jan BürgerVfL Wolfsburg
7yr to peak+44%
1.0M1.8M
Karim CoulibalySV Werder Bremen
7yr to peak+44%
20.0M35.7M
Niklas SwiderBorussia Mönchengladbach
7yr to peak+40%
250K415K
Patrice CovicSV Werder Bremen
7yr to peak+40%
4.0M6.6M
David Santos DaiberBayern Munich
7yr to peak+40%
1.0M1.7M
Yan DiomandeRB Leipzig
7yr to peak+40%
45.0M74.8M
RankPlayerAgeYears to PeakCurrentPeak ForecastRPP %
#1
Axel Tape
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
1888.0M15.4M+48%
#2
Dennis Seimen
VfB Stuttgart
2067.0M13.5M+48%
#3
Tiago Pereira Cardoso
Borussia Mönchengladbach
2061.5M2.9M+48%
#4
Max Schmitt
Bayern Munich
206500K961K+48%
#5
Lennart Karl
Bayern Munich
18860.0M107.2M+44%
#6
Luca Erlein
TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
1971.3M2.3M+44%
#7
Kacper Koscierski
VfL Bochum
197700K1.3M+44%
#8
Noahkai Banks
FC Augsburg
19715.0M26.8M+44%
#9
Jaaso Jantunen
SC Freiburg
215400K715K+44%
#10
Jan Bürger
VfL Wolfsburg
1971.0M1.8M+44%
#11
Karim Coulibaly
SV Werder Bremen
19720.0M35.7M+44%
#12
Niklas Swider
Borussia Mönchengladbach
197250K415K+40%
#13
Patrice Covic
SV Werder Bremen
1974.0M6.6M+40%
#14
David Santos Daiber
Bayern Munich
1971.0M1.7M+40%
#15
Yan Diomande
RB Leipzig
19745.0M74.8M+40%
#16
Elias Baum
Eintracht Frankfurt
2061.0M1.7M+40%
#17
Christopher Olivier
VfB Stuttgart
206500K831K+40%
#18
Bruno Ogbus
SC Freiburg
2061.0M1.7M+40%
#19
Finn Jeltsch
VfB Stuttgart
20625.0M41.5M+40%
#20
Jahmai Simpson-Pusey
1.FC Köln
2064.0M6.6M+40%

Risk-Adjusted Upside (RAU)

Upside potential weighted against forecast uncertainty. Higher RAU = better risk-reward profile.

Understanding Risk-Adjusted Upside (RAU)

Borussia Mönchengladbach's Tiago Pereira Cardoso has the highest Risk-Adjusted Upside at 118.5. That means Tiago Pereira Cardoso has 28% upside potential with only 0% forecast uncertainty-representing excellent risk-reward for value appreciation.

In second is Bayern Munich's Max Schmitt with a 118.5 RAU (28% upside, 0% uncertainty). Third is Dennis Seimen of VfB Stuttgart with a 118.5 RAU (28% upside, 0% uncertainty).

How RAU is calculated: RAU divides upside potential by forecast uncertainty (RAU = Upside % ÷ Uncertainty %). A RAU of 118.5 means the upside is 118.5× greater than the uncertainty-making it a high-confidence growth opportunity. Target RAU ≥2.0 for balanced risk-reward.

Risk-Adjusted Upside by Player

Tiago Pereira CardosoBorussia Mönchengladbach
28% / ±0%118.5
Range: €1.7M - €2.1M
Max SchmittBayern Munich
28% / ±0%118.5
Range: €581K - €698K
Dennis SeimenVfB Stuttgart
28% / ±0%118.5
Range: €8.1M - €9.8M
Jaaso JantunenSC Freiburg
23% / ±0%103.3
Range: €448K - €539K
Lúkas PeterssonTSG 1899 Hoffenheim
19% / ±0%100.1
Range: €657K - €772K
Jonas UrbigBayern Munich
19% / ±0%100.1
Range: €2.2M - €2.6M
Frank Feller1. Fußballclub Heidenheim 1846
19% / ±0%100.1
Range: €548K - €643K
Mio BackhausSV Werder Bremen
19% / ±0%100.1
Range: €11.0M - €12.9M
Axel TapeBayer 04 Leverkusen
28% / ±0%94.8
Range: €9.1M - €11.4M
Karim CoulibalySV Werder Bremen
23% / ±0%82.7
Range: €21.9M - €27.5M
Luca ErleinTSG 1899 Hoffenheim
23% / ±0%82.7
Range: €1.4M - €1.8M
Kacper KoscierskiVfL Bochum
23% / ±0%82.7
Range: €765K - €964K
Noahkai BanksFC Augsburg
23% / ±0%82.7
Range: €16.4M - €20.7M
Jan BürgerVfL Wolfsburg
23% / ±0%82.7
Range: €1.1M - €1.4M
Nahuel NollTSG 1899 Hoffenheim
15% / ±0%79.9
Range: €527K - €619K
RankPlayerExpectedRangeUpside %RAU
#1
Tiago Pereira Cardoso
Borussia Mönchengladbach
1.9M1.7M-2.1M+28%118.5
#2
Max Schmitt
Bayern Munich
639K581K-698K+28%118.5
#3
Dennis Seimen
VfB Stuttgart
9.0M8.1M-9.8M+28%118.5
#4
Jaaso Jantunen
SC Freiburg
494K448K-539K+23%103.3
#5
Lúkas Petersson
TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
714K657K-772K+19%100.1
#6
Jonas Urbig
Bayern Munich
2.4M2.2M-2.6M+19%100.1
#7
Frank Feller
1. Fußballclub Heidenheim 1846
595K548K-643K+19%100.1
#8
Mio Backhaus
SV Werder Bremen
11.9M11.0M-12.9M+19%100.1
#9
Axel Tape
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
10.2M9.1M-11.4M+28%94.8
#10
Karim Coulibaly
SV Werder Bremen
24.7M21.9M-27.5M+23%82.7
#11
Luca Erlein
TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
1.6M1.4M-1.8M+23%82.7
#12
Kacper Koscierski
VfL Bochum
864K765K-964K+23%82.7
#13
Noahkai Banks
FC Augsburg
18.5M16.4M-20.7M+23%82.7
#14
Jan Bürger
VfL Wolfsburg
1.2M1.1M-1.4M+23%82.7
#15
Nahuel Noll
TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
573K527K-619K+15%79.9
#16
Johannes Schenk
Bayern Munich
287K264K-310K+15%79.9
#17
Niklas Sauter
SC Freiburg
287K264K-310K+15%79.9
#18
Tjark Ernst
Hertha BSC
1.7M1.6M-1.9M+15%79.9
#19
Kauã Santos
Eintracht Frankfurt
8.0M7.4M-8.7M+15%79.9
#20
Lennart Karl
Bayern Munich
77.1M65.6M-88.6M+29%74.2

Roster Pressure Index (RPI)

Squad depth pressure based on Z-score distribution. Negative RPI = thin depth, positive = deep roster.

What This Shows

Z-Score explained: Measures how many standard deviations a player's strength is from the position average. Z-Score = 0 means average, +1.0 is one standard deviation above average, -1.0 is below average.

How to use: RPI < -1.0 indicates critical depth shortage. These positions need immediate reinforcement. RPI > +1.0 suggests strong depth, allowing selective, high-value additions only.

Current market: young player position shows strong depth (avg Z-score: 0.00). RPI: 0.00.

Position Depth Analysis

179
Total Players
0.00
Avg Z-Score
0.00
RPI Score
Weak DepthStrong Depth
-3.00+3.0

Highest Z-Scores

Jamal Musiala+7.64
Xavi Simons+4.50
Aleksandar Pavlovic+3.56
Lennart Karl+3.24
Castello Lukeba+2.30

Lowest Z-Scores

Niklas Swider-0.52
Davis Bautista-0.52
Niklas Sauter-0.52
Johannes Schenk-0.52
Malick Sanogo-0.52

Age-Share Concentration (ASC)

Identifies players capturing disproportionate value relative to age group representation. Positive ASC = value concentration.

Understanding Age-Share Concentration (ASC)

Borussia Dortmund's Jordi Paulina in the 21-23 age bracket has the highest Age-Share Concentration at +-3.0%. That means Jamal Musiala captures 74.7% of total market value while representing only 77.7% of players in their age group-showing dominant elite status.

In second is Borussia Mönchengladbach's Shio Fukuda with a +-3.0% ASC (74.7% value share vs 77.7% player share in 21-23 bracket). Third is Aarón Anselmino of Borussia Dortmund with a +-3.0% ASC (74.7% value vs 77.7% players in 21-23 bracket).

How ASC is calculated: ASC = (% of total value) - (% of total players) in age bracket. A +-3.0% ASC means the player captures -3.0% more market value than their numerical representation-indicating marquee status. ASC > +15% = elite dominance, ASC < -15% = potential value targets.

Value Concentration by Player

Jordi PaulinaBorussia Dortmund
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Shio FukudaBorussia Mönchengladbach
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Aarón AnselminoBorussia Dortmund
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Lilian EgloffVfB Stuttgart
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Paul Nebel1.FSV Mainz 05
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Joe ScallyBorussia Mönchengladbach
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Giovanni ReynaBorussia Dortmund
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Mehdi LouneEintracht Frankfurt
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Lion SemicBorussia Dortmund
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Lasse GüntherFC Augsburg
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Luca NetzBorussia Mönchengladbach
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Fisnik AsllaniTSG 1899 Hoffenheim
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Luca JaquezVfB Stuttgart
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Tjark ErnstHertha BSC
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
Johan BakayokoRB Leipzig
21-23-3.0%
74.7% value share / 77.7% player share
RankPlayerAge BracketValue SharePlayer ShareASC
#1
Jordi Paulina
Borussia Dortmund
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#2
Shio Fukuda
Borussia Mönchengladbach
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#3
Aarón Anselmino
Borussia Dortmund
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#4
Lilian Egloff
VfB Stuttgart
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#5
Paul Nebel
1.FSV Mainz 05
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#6
Joe Scally
Borussia Mönchengladbach
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#7
Giovanni Reyna
Borussia Dortmund
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#8
Mehdi Loune
Eintracht Frankfurt
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#9
Lion Semic
Borussia Dortmund
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#10
Lasse Günther
FC Augsburg
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#11
Luca Netz
Borussia Mönchengladbach
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#12
Fisnik Asllani
TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#13
Luca Jaquez
VfB Stuttgart
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#14
Tjark Ernst
Hertha BSC
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#15
Johan Bakayoko
RB Leipzig
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#16
Xavi Simons
RB Leipzig
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#17
Umut Tohumcu
TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#18
Armindo Sieb
1.FSV Mainz 05
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#19
Luis Hartwig
VfL Bochum
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%
#20
Mohamed Sankoh
VfB Stuttgart
21-2374.7%77.7%-3.0%

Buy-Now vs Wait-List Map

Categorizes players by age position and upside potential to guide timing of acquisition.

What This Shows

How to use:"Buy Now - High Upside" = immediate priority targets."Watch List" = monitor for 6-12 months."Peak" = pay premium for proven performers."Aging" = short-term depth only.

Current market: 28 immediate targets, 151 standard acquisitions, 0 watch-list prospects, 0 at peak.

BUY NOW - High Upside

Lennart Karl
18yo • Bayern Munich
60.0M
Can Uzun
20yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
45.0M
Yan Diomande
19yo • RB Leipzig
45.0M
Finn Jeltsch
20yo • VfB Stuttgart
25.0M
Bazoumana Touré
20yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
25.0M
Karim Coulibaly
19yo • SV Werder Bremen
20.0M
Noahkai Banks
19yo • FC Augsburg
15.0M
Mio Backhaus
22yo • SV Werder Bremen
10.0M
Axel Tape
18yo • Bayer 04 Leverkusen
8.0M
Dennis Seimen
20yo • VfB Stuttgart
7.0M
Francis Onyeka
19yo • Bayer 04 Leverkusen
6.0M
Jahmai Simpson-Pusey
20yo • 1.FC Köln
4.0M
Patrice Covic
19yo • SV Werder Bremen
4.0M
Almugera Kabar
20yo • Borussia Dortmund
3.0M
Jonas Urbig
22yo • Bayern Munich
2.0M
Tiago Pereira Cardoso
20yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
1.5M
Luca Erlein
19yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
1.3M
Bruno Ogbus
20yo • SC Freiburg
1.0M
Elias Baum
20yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
1.0M
Jan Bürger
19yo • VfL Wolfsburg
1.0M
David Santos Daiber
19yo • Bayern Munich
1.0M
Kacper Koscierski
19yo • VfL Bochum
700K
Lúkas Petersson
22yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
600K
Frank Feller
22yo • 1. Fußballclub Heidenheim 1846
500K
Max Schmitt
20yo • Bayern Munich
500K
Christopher Olivier
20yo • VfB Stuttgart
500K
Jaaso Jantunen
21yo • SC Freiburg
400K
Niklas Swider
19yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
250K

WATCH LIST - High Upside

No players in this category

BUY NOW - Medium Upside

Jamal Musiala
23yo • Bayern Munich
130.0M
Xavi Simons
23yo • RB Leipzig
80.0M
Aleksandar Pavlovic
22yo • Bayern Munich
65.0M
Castello Lukeba
23yo • RB Leipzig
45.0M
Jarell Quansah
23yo • Bayer 04 Leverkusen
40.0M
Hugo Larsson
22yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
40.0M
Tom Bischof
21yo • Bayern Munich
40.0M
Nathaniel Brown
23yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
35.0M
Antonio Nusa
21yo • RB Leipzig
32.0M
Bilal El Khannouss
22yo • VfB Stuttgart
30.0M
Maximilian Beier
23yo • Borussia Dortmund
30.0M
Brajan Gruda
22yo • RB Leipzig
28.0M
Johan Manzambi
20yo • SC Freiburg
30.0M
Konstantinos Koulierakis
22yo • VfL Wolfsburg
25.0M
Johan Bakayoko
23yo • RB Leipzig
25.0M
Carney Chukwuemeka
22yo • Borussia Dortmund
25.0M
Jean-Mattéo Bahoya
21yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
25.0M
Conrad Harder
21yo • RB Leipzig
24.0M
Eliesse Ben Seghir
21yo • Bayer 04 Leverkusen
24.0M
Jobe Bellingham
20yo • Borussia Dortmund
25.0M
Leopold Querfeld
22yo • 1.FC Union Berlin
18.0M
Paul Nebel
23yo • 1.FSV Mainz 05
18.0M
Ezechiel Banzuzi
21yo • RB Leipzig
18.0M
Farès Chaïbi
23yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
15.0M
Nnamdi Collins
22yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
15.0M
El Chadaille Bitshiabu
21yo • RB Leipzig
15.0M
Chema Andrés
21yo • VfB Stuttgart
15.0M
Aarón Anselmino
21yo • Borussia Dortmund
12.0M
Jeanuël Belocian
21yo • Bayer 04 Leverkusen
12.0M
Nelson Weiper
21yo • 1.FSV Mainz 05
12.0M
Badredine Bouanani
21yo • VfB Stuttgart
12.0M
Mert Kömür
21yo • FC Augsburg
12.0M
Luca Jaquez
23yo • VfB Stuttgart
10.0M
Tom Rothe
21yo • 1.FC Union Berlin
10.0M
Aljoscha Kemlein
21yo • 1.FC Union Berlin
9.0M
Max Rosenfelder
23yo • SC Freiburg
8.0M
Arthur
23yo • Bayer 04 Leverkusen
7.0M
Joe Scally
23yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
7.0M
Ismaël Gharbi
22yo • FC Augsburg
7.0M
Kauã Santos
23yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
7.0M
Lukas Ullrich
22yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
7.0M
Oscar Højlund
21yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
7.5M
Igor Matanovic
23yo • SC Freiburg
7.0M
Julien Duranville
20yo • Borussia Dortmund
7.5M
Max Moerstedt
20yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
7.0M
Luca Netz
23yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
6.0M
Bence Dárdai
20yo • VfL Wolfsburg
7.0M
Giovanni Reyna
23yo • Borussia Dortmund
6.0M
Aurèle Amenda
22yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
6.0M
Max Finkgräfe
22yo • RB Leipzig
6.0M
Noel Aseko
20yo • Bayern Munich
6.0M
Keke Topp
22yo • SV Werder Bremen
5.0M
Kevin Paredes
23yo • VfL Wolfsburg
5.0M
Umut Tohumcu
21yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
5.0M
Cole Campbell
20yo • Borussia Dortmund
5.0M
Arijon Ibrahimovic
20yo • 1. Fußballclub Heidenheim 1846
5.0M
Ísak Jóhannesson
23yo • 1.FC Köln
3.5M
Maurice Krattenmacher
20yo • Bayern Munich
3.5M
Kjell Wätjen
20yo • Borussia Dortmund
3.5M
Oscar Fraulo
22yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
3.0M
Fabio Chiarodia
21yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
3.0M
Farid Alfa-Ruprecht
20yo • Bayer 04 Leverkusen
3.0M
John Tolkin
23yo • Holstein Kiel
2.5M
Filippo Mane
21yo • Borussia Dortmund
2.5M
Mats Pannewig
21yo • VfL Bochum
2.5M
Damion Downs
22yo • Hamburger SV
2.0M
Oscar Vilhelmsson
22yo • SV Darmstadt 98
2.0M
Mika Baur
22yo • SC Freiburg
1.8M
Alejo Sarco
20yo • Bayer 04 Leverkusen
2.0M
Linus Gechter
22yo • Hertha BSC
1.8M
Justin Diehl
21yo • VfB Stuttgart
1.8M
Krisztián Lisztes
21yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
1.7M
Jarzinho Malanga
20yo • VfB Stuttgart
1.7M
Nikolas Veratschnig
23yo • 1.FSV Mainz 05
1.5M
Armindo Sieb
23yo • 1.FSV Mainz 05
1.5M
Tjark Ernst
23yo • Hertha BSC
1.5M
Jens Castrop
22yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
1.5M
Robert Wagner
23yo • FC St. Pauli
1.4M
Aaron Zehnter
21yo • VfL Wolfsburg
1.5M
Abdoulaye Kamara
21yo • Borussia Dortmund
1.5M
Paul Hennrich
21yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
1.2M
Benjamin Boakye
21yo • VfB Stuttgart
1.2M
David Mokwa
22yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
1.0M
Nemanja Motika
23yo • Bayern Munich
1.0M
Marten Winkler
23yo • Hertha BSC
1.0M
Grant-Leon Ranos
23yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
1.0M
Dzenan Pejcinovic
21yo • VfL Wolfsburg
1.0M
Muhammed Damar
22yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
1.0M
William Mikelbrencis
22yo • Hamburger SV
1.0M
Anton Kade
22yo • FC Augsburg
900K
Shio Fukuda
22yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
800K
Fisnik Asllani
23yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
800K
Lilian Egloff
23yo • VfB Stuttgart
800K
Lucas Copado
22yo • Bayern Munich
750K
Lasse Günther
23yo • FC Augsburg
800K
Mohamed Sankoh
22yo • VfB Stuttgart
700K
Joshua Quarshie
21yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
800K
Isak Hansen-Aarøen
21yo • SV Werder Bremen
800K
Derry Scherhant
23yo • SC Freiburg
700K
Bambasé Conté
23yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
700K
Yannik Lührs
22yo • Borussia Dortmund
700K
Satoshi Tanaka
23yo • Fortuna Düsseldorf
650K
Jovan Milosevic
20yo • SV Werder Bremen
700K
Noah Pesch
21yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
600K
Kyliane Dong
21yo • FC Augsburg
600K
Guille Bueno
23yo • Borussia Dortmund
600K
Marcel Wenig
22yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
600K
Leon Opitz
21yo • SV Werder Bremen
600K
Ibrahim Maza
20yo • Bayer 04 Leverkusen
600K
Thomas Kastanaras
23yo • FC Augsburg
500K
Fabio Torsiello
21yo • SV Darmstadt 98
500K
Jordi Paulina
21yo • Borussia Dortmund
500K
Samuel Bamba
22yo • VfL Bochum
450K
Justin Janitzek
22yo • Bayern Munich
500K
Sanoussy Ba
22yo • RB Leipzig
500K
Nahuel Noll
23yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
500K
Bennit Bröger
20yo • VfL Wolfsburg
500K
Florian Micheler
21yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
500K
Laurin Ulrich
21yo • VfB Stuttgart
500K
Simon Walde
21yo • Borussia Mönchengladbach
500K
Fin Stevens
23yo • FC St. Pauli
450K
Noel Futkeu
23yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
400K
Ben Bobzien
23yo • 1.FSV Mainz 05
400K
Samuele Di Benedetto
21yo • VfB Stuttgart
450K
Yann Sturm
21yo • SC Freiburg
450K
Luca Raimund
21yo • VfB Stuttgart
400K
Noah König
23yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
400K
Dario Gebuhr
23yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
400K
Rav van den Berg
22yo • 1.FC Köln
400K
Kofi Amoako
21yo • VfL Wolfsburg
400K
Hennes Behrens
21yo • 1. Fußballclub Heidenheim 1846
400K
David Preu
21yo • 1.FC Union Berlin
400K
Luis Hartwig
23yo • VfL Bochum
350K
Julian Eitschberger
22yo • Hertha BSC
350K
Dion Berisha
23yo • FC Augsburg
300K
Noah Fenyő
20yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
350K
Luka Duric
23yo • TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
300K
Juan Cabrera
23yo • FC Augsburg
300K
Enrique Herrero
21yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
300K
Mehdi Loune
22yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
300K
Lion Semic
22yo • Borussia Dortmund
300K
Tarek Buchmann
21yo • Bayern Munich
300K
Daniel Gleiber
21yo • 1.FSV Mainz 05
300K
Ayman Aourir
21yo • Bayer 04 Leverkusen
300K
Sidney Raebiger
21yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
300K
Malick Sanogo
22yo • 1.FC Union Berlin
250K
Pascal Klemens
21yo • Hertha BSC
300K
Philipp Schulz
21yo • 1.FSV Mainz 05
300K
Johannes Schenk
23yo • Bayern Munich
250K
Niklas Sauter
23yo • SC Freiburg
250K
Davis Bautista
21yo • Eintracht Frankfurt
250K

PEAK Players

No players in this category

Price vs Peer Z-Score

IQR-based pricing analysis relative to position peers. Identifies over/undervalued players vs market.

What This Shows

How to use: Z-score < -1.5 = significantly undervalued (potential bargain). Z-score > +1.5 = premium pricing (requires strong justification). Within ±1.0 = fair market value.

Current market: Position median is €80.0M. 3 undervalued, 13 premium.

Value Positioning vs Peers

Arijon Ibrahimovic1. Fußballclub Heidenheim 1846
5.0M-2.00
Undervalued
Cole CampbellBorussia Dortmund
5.0M-2.00
Undervalued
Noahkai BanksFC Augsburg
15.0M-2.00
Undervalued
Maximilian BeierBorussia Dortmund
30.0M-1.25
Undervalued
Bilal El KhannoussVfB Stuttgart
30.0M-1.25
Undervalued
Karim CoulibalySV Werder Bremen
20.0M-1.00
Fair value
Antonio NusaRB Leipzig
32.0M-1.00
Fair value
Noel AsekoBayern Munich
6.0M-1.00
Fair value
Johan ManzambiSC Freiburg
30.0M-1.00
Fair value
Francis OnyekaBayer 04 Leverkusen
6.0M-1.00
Fair value
Nnamdi CollinsEintracht Frankfurt
15.0M-0.90
Fair value
El Chadaille BitshiabuRB Leipzig
15.0M-0.90
Fair value
Farès ChaïbiEintracht Frankfurt
15.0M-0.90
Fair value
Chema AndrésVfB Stuttgart
15.0M-0.90
Fair value
Nathaniel BrownEintracht Frankfurt
35.0M-0.63
Fair value
PlayerMarket ValuePosition MedianZ-ScoreAssessment
Arijon Ibrahimovic
1. Fußballclub Heidenheim 1846
5.0M1.5M-2.00Undervalued
Cole Campbell
Borussia Dortmund
5.0M1.5M-2.00Undervalued
Noahkai Banks
FC Augsburg
15.0M1.5M-2.00Undervalued
Maximilian Beier
Borussia Dortmund
30.0M1.5M-1.25Good Value
Bilal El Khannouss
VfB Stuttgart
30.0M1.5M-1.25Good Value
Karim Coulibaly
SV Werder Bremen
20.0M1.5M-1.00Good Value
Antonio Nusa
RB Leipzig
32.0M1.5M-1.00Good Value
Noel Aseko
Bayern Munich
6.0M1.5M-1.00Good Value
Johan Manzambi
SC Freiburg
30.0M1.5M-1.00Good Value
Francis Onyeka
Bayer 04 Leverkusen
6.0M1.5M-1.00Good Value
Nnamdi Collins
Eintracht Frankfurt
15.0M1.5M-0.90Good Value
El Chadaille Bitshiabu
RB Leipzig
15.0M1.5M-0.90Good Value
Farès Chaïbi
Eintracht Frankfurt
15.0M1.5M-0.90Good Value
Chema Andrés
VfB Stuttgart
15.0M1.5M-0.90Good Value
Nathaniel Brown
Eintracht Frankfurt
35.0M1.5M-0.63Good Value
Paul Nebel
1.FSV Mainz 05
18.0M1.5M-0.60Good Value
Leopold Querfeld
1.FC Union Berlin
18.0M1.5M-0.60Good Value
Ezechiel Banzuzi
RB Leipzig
18.0M1.5M-0.60Good Value
Johannes Schenk
Bayern Munich
250K1.5M-0.58Good Value
Niklas Sauter
SC Freiburg
250K1.5M-0.58Good Value

Market Overview: Bundesliga Young Players 2022-23

Our database tracked 179 Bundesliga Young Players in the 2022-23 season, representing 23 clubs with a combined market value of €1.5B. The average market value for Bundesliga Young Players was €8.5M, with the average age at 21 years old.

The most valuable young player in the Bundesliga was Jamal Musiala, worth €130.0M and played for Bayern Munich at 23 years old. The top 5 Young Players averaged €76.0M in market value, including Xavi Simons and Aleksandar Pavlovic.

Age distribution showed the youngest tracked young player was Lennart Karl (18 years, Bayern Munich, €60.0M), while the oldest was Jamal Musiala (23 years, Bayern Munich, €130.0M). Research shows Young Players typically peak at age 26-27.

Historical analysis showed 179 Young Players (100%) increased in market value over the following 12 months based on age-curve trajectories, then-current performance trends, and playing time analysis. The Bundesliga market for Young Players remained highly competitive with significant transfer activity in the 2022-23 season.

How We Rank Bundesliga Young Players

Our Analytical Strength Index is calibrated specifically for young players, using position-specific age curves and playing time benchmarks. The model draws from academic research on player valuation (Franck & Nüesch, 2012) and age-performance curves (Dendir, 2016).

Scoring Components for ALL

Historical Achievement Index (35%)

Peak career market value for Bundesliga young players, reflecting proven track record and reputation. Uses log-scale to account for exponential value distribution at elite level.

Current Performance Proxy (30%)

Present market value for Bundesliga young players, capturing recent form, injuries, and current performance level. Weighted to reflect age-related depreciation patterns.

Playing Time Utilization (18%)

Midfielders with 2,400+ minutes score highest, indicating regular starting role and sustained performance.

Age-Adjusted Performance Curve (12%)

Midfielders peak at 26-27 with 6.0%/year decline. Pre-peak players score higher on development trajectory.

Competition Level Adjustment (3%)

Bundesliga receives Top 5 European league premium for competitive intensity and quality of opposition.

Performance Expectations Multiplier (2%)

Players at clubs with Champions League pedigree face higher performance standards and tactical complexity, contributing to development and market validation.

ALL Performance Benchmarks

Peak Age: 26-27 years (technical skill and tactical awareness)

Decline Rate: 6.0% per year (technical skills age better than physical attributes)

Optimal Minutes: 2,400-2,500 per season (balance of involvement and recovery)

1-Year Market Value Forecast

Probabilistic model combining age-curve depreciation, value momentum, and playing time factors:

Age Factor: Midfielder -6.0%/year post-peak, +5%/year pre-peak

Value Trajectory: Near career peak (>95% of peak value): +3% momentum | Moderate decline: -5%

Playing Time Factor: Regular starters (+2%), Squad rotation (-2%)

Forecast Range: ±12-15% confidence interval

Research Foundation

Dendir (2016): Age-performance curves for young players

Carmichael et al. (2011): Player depreciation in top leagues

Franck & Nüesch (2012): Hedonic pricing models for talent valuation

Szymanski, S. (2015). Money and Soccer: A Soccernomics Guide

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Bundesliga Young Players in the 2022-23 season

Who are the most valuable Young Players in the Bundesliga in 2022-23?

The most valuable young player in the Bundesliga in 2022-23 is Jamal Musiala, who is worth €130.0M and plays for Bayern Munich. The second most valuable is Xavi Simons (€80.0M, RB Leipzig), followed by Aleksandar Pavlovic (€65.0M, Bayern Munich). Our database tracks 179 Bundesliga Young Players with comprehensive market valuations updated for the 2022-23 season.

How are Bundesliga Young Players ranked?

Bundesliga Young Players are ranked by our proprietary Analytical Strength Index, which is specifically calibrated for Young Players. The score combines six factors: Historical Achievement Index (35%) measuring peak career value, Current Performance Proxy (30%) reflecting recent market signals, Playing Time Utilization (18%) tracking minutes played, Age-Adjusted Performance Curve (12%) using position-specific peak ages, League Quality Coefficient (3%) for Bundesliga competition level, and Club Tier Multiplier (2%) accounting for club prestige. This methodology is grounded in academic research including work by Dendir (2016) on age-performance curves and Franck & Nüesch (2012) on hedonic pricing models.

What age do Young Players peak?

How much does it cost to sign a top young player from the Bundesliga?

Transfer fees for Bundesliga Young Players vary significantly based on market value, contract length, and club bargaining position. For the top-ranked young player Jamal Musiala (market value: €130.0M), estimated transfer fees would range from €104.0M to €182.0M depending on contract situation. Players with longer contracts (3+ years) command premium fees (1.2-1.4× market value), while those in the final year may be available for 0.8-1.1× market value. Our fee estimates are derived from historical transfer patterns and contract-clock modifiers validated against actual Bundesliga transactions.

What is the value forecast for Bundesliga Young Players?

Our 1-year forecast model projects market value changes for Bundesliga Young Players based on age-curve depreciation, historical trajectory, and playing time adjustments. The forecast combines three factors: age-based appreciation/depreciation (pre-peak players gain ~5% per year toward peak age, post-peak players decline at position-specific rates), market trajectory momentum (comparing current to peak value), and playing time confidence (regular starters receive +2% boost). Forecast confidence intervals account for position-specific volatility-midfielders have ±12-15% volatility. Young players (under 22) and older players (over 32) receive 1.15× uncertainty multipliers due to unpredictable development or decline patterns.

Where does the Bundesliga young player data come from?

Our Bundesliga young player data is sourced from Football Analytics AI's proprietary Transfer Intelligence Database, which aggregates market valuations, player statistics, contract information, and transfer histories from multiple industry sources. Market values are updated regularly based on player performance, injuries, contract negotiations, and transfer market activity. We enhance this data with our proprietary analytics including position-specific scoring algorithms, age-performance curves calibrated to academic research, and statistical forecast models. All data is validated against official Bundesliga sources and updated monthly for the 2022-23 season to ensure accuracy for recruitment and investment decisions.