Best Goalkeepers in the MLS (Jun 2026)
Ranked by Analytical Strength Score
Market Overview: MLS Goalkeepers 2023-24
Our database tracked 63 MLS Goalkeepers in the 2023-24 season, representing 30 clubs with a combined market value of €48.0M. The average market value for MLS Goalkeepers was €762K, with the average age at 28.6 years old.
The most valuable goalkeeper in the MLS was Patrick Schulte, worth €3.5M and played for Columbus Crew at 25 years old. The top 5 Goalkeepers averaged €3.1M in market value, including Yohei Takaoka and Dayne St. Clair.
Age distribution showed the youngest tracked goalkeeper was Duran Ferree (19 years, San Diego FC, €150K), while the oldest was Stefan Frei (40 years, Seattle Sounders FC, €150K). Research shows Goalkeepers typically peak at age 29.
Historical analysis showed 33 Goalkeepers (52%) increased in market value over the following 12 months based on age-curve trajectories, then-current performance trends, and playing time analysis. The MLS market for Goalkeepers remained actively developing with emerging talent in the 2023-24 season.
💡 Use the search bar below to find specific players, or apply filters to narrow results by club, age range, or market value. Click the chart icon next to any player to view their historical value trajectory and forecast.
Explore Market Size by Position in MLS
Interactive bubble chart showing predicted 2-year growth vs current age for all MLS Goalkeepers. Identify undervalued assets and track market momentum across 30 clubs with €48.0M combined value.
Age Distribution: MLS Goalkeepers
The MLS GK market shows 5 distinct age segments, with the largest cohort in the 30+ bracket (27 players, 43% of market). The 30+ age group holds the most value at €19.9M, averaging €739K per player.
Top Goalkeepers by Age Bracket
U21 Years (3 players)
21-23 Years (6 players)
24-26 Years (16 players)
27-29 Years (11 players)
Market Value Distribution
Elite Tier Concentration
The top 7 Goalkeepers (11% of players) control €20.5M
Market Tiers
Market structure shows concentrated value with emerging (<€5m) tier representing 100% of the MLS GK pool.
Emerging (<€5M)
Club Distribution: MLS Goalkeepers
Among 30 MLS clubs, Inter Miami CF leads with 3 Goalkeepers worth €4.5M (averaging €1.5M per player). The top 10 clubs account for 37% of tracked Goalkeepers.
Inter Miami CF (3 Goalkeepers)
Vancouver Whitecaps FC (3 Goalkeepers)
Columbus Crew (2 Goalkeepers)
CF Montréal (3 Goalkeepers)
Player Rankings
Ranked by APE Strength Score. Click any player to view full profile, or click the chart icon to see value history.
Patrick Schulte
Columbus Crew • 25 years old
€3.0M
€3.5M
+15.6%
Expected: €3.7M
48.5
Yohei Takaoka
Vancouver Whitecaps FC • 30 years old
€3.7M
€3.5M
-5.4%
Expected: €3.1M
47.6
Dayne St. Clair
Inter Miami CF • 29 years old
€3.0M
€3.5M
+15.6%
Expected: €3.6M
47.2
Maxime Crépeau
Orlando City SC • 32 years old
€3.2M
€2.5M
-22.6%
Expected: €2.1M
40.8
Roman Celentano
FC Cincinnati • 25 years old
€2.2M
€2.5M
+15.6%
Expected: €2.6M
40.8
Matt Turner
New England Revolution • 31 years old
€3.2M
€2.5M
-22.6%
Expected: €2.2M
40.4
Chris Brady
Chicago Fire FC • 22 years old
€2.2M
€2.5M
+15.6%
Expected: €3.0M
40.2
Matt Freese
New York City FC • 27 years old
€1.7M
€2.0M
+15.6%
Expected: €2.0M
37.6
Zack Steffen
Colorado Rapids • 31 years old
€2.3M
€1.8M
-22.6%
Expected: €1.6M
36.1
Thomas Gillier
CF Montréal • 22 years old
€1.6M
€1.8M
+15.6%
Expected: €2.1M
36.0
Kristijan Kahlina
Charlotte FC • 33 years old
€1.9M
€1.5M
-22.6%
Expected: €1.3M
34.7
CJ dos Santos
San Diego FC • 25 years old
€1.3M
€1.5M
+15.6%
Expected: €1.6M
34.2
Maarten Paes
FC Dallas • 28 years old
€1.3M
€1.5M
+15.6%
Expected: €1.5M
33.4
Roman Bürki
St. Louis CITY SC • 35 years old
€1.5M
€1.2M
-22.6%
Expected: €1.1M
32.6
Hugo Lloris
Los Angeles FC • 39 years old
€1.3M
€1.0M
-22.6%
Expected: €898K
32.1
Jonathan Sirois
CF Montréal • 24 years old
€865K
€1.0M
+15.6%
Expected: €1.1M
28.7
Ethan Horvath
New York Red Bulls • 30 years old
€1.1M
€1.0M
-5.4%
Expected: €898K
28.1
James Pantemis
Portland Timbers • 29 years old
€865K
€1.0M
+15.6%
Expected: €1.0M
27.6
Daniel
San Jose Earthquakes • 32 years old
€1.0M
€800K
-22.6%
Expected: €681K
26.1
John Pulskamp
Sporting Kansas City • 25 years old
€519K
€600K
+15.6%
Expected: €635K
22.3
Scout Tools
Advanced analytics for scouting and recruitment decisions. Each tool provides unique insights into player value, potential, and market dynamics.
Pre-Peak Value Efficiency (PPVE)
Identifies pre-peak players offering exceptional value relative to their age bracket. Higher PPVE = better value.
Understanding Pre-Peak Value Efficiency (PPVE)
Columbus Crew's Patrick Schulte at 25 years old has the highest Pre-Peak Value Efficiency at 5.83×. That means Patrick Schulte is valued 5.83× higher than the median player in the 24-26 age bracket—representing exceptional value before reaching peak age.
In second is Chicago Fire FC's Chris Brady, who is 22 years old, with a 4.17× PPVE. Third is Roman Celentano of FC Cincinnati, who is 25 years old with a 4.17× PPVE.
How PPVE is calculated: PPVE compares a player's current market value to the median value of all players in their age bracket. A PPVE of 5.83× means the player is worth 483% more than typical players their age—making them high-value targets before they reach peak value.
PPVE by Age Bracket
| Rank | Player | Age | Bracket | Current Value | Bracket Median | PPVE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Patrick Schulte Columbus Crew | 25 | 24-26 | €3.5M | €600K | 5.83× |
| #2 | Chris Brady Chicago Fire FC | 22 | 21-23 | €2.5M | €600K | 4.17× |
| #3 | Roman Celentano FC Cincinnati | 25 | 24-26 | €2.5M | €600K | 4.17× |
| #4 | Thomas Gillier CF Montréal | 22 | 21-23 | €1.8M | €600K | 3.00× |
| #5 | CJ dos Santos San Diego FC | 25 | 24-26 | €1.5M | €600K | 2.50× |
| #6 | Andrew Rick Philadelphia Union | 20 | U21 | €400K | €200K | 2.00× |
| #7 | Jonathan Sirois CF Montréal | 24 | 24-26 | €1.0M | €600K | 1.67× |
| #8 | John Pulskamp Sporting Kansas City | 25 | 24-26 | €600K | €600K | 1.00× |
| #9 | Novak Mićović Los Angeles Galaxy | 24 | 24-26 | €600K | €600K | 1.00× |
| #10 | Rocco Ríos Novo Inter Miami CF | 23 | 21-23 | €600K | €600K | 1.00× |
| #11 | Adam Beaudry Colorado Rapids | 20 | U21 | €200K | €200K | 1.00× |
| #12 | Jayden Hibbert Atlanta United FC | 21 | 21-23 | €500K | €600K | 0.83× |
| #13 | Duran Ferree San Diego FC | 19 | U21 | €150K | €200K | 0.75× |
| #14 | Michael Collodi FC Dallas | 25 | 24-26 | €400K | €600K | 0.67× |
| #15 | Nicolas Hansen Colorado Rapids | 24 | 24-26 | €300K | €600K | 0.50× |
| #16 | Isaac Boehmer Vancouver Whitecaps FC | 24 | 24-26 | €250K | €600K | 0.42× |
| #17 | Blake Gillingham Houston Dynamo FC | 23 | 21-23 | €150K | €600K | 0.25× |
| #18 | Tomás Romero New York City FC | 25 | 24-26 | €150K | €600K | 0.25× |
| #19 | Hunter Sulte Portland Timbers | 24 | 24-26 | €150K | €600K | 0.25× |
| #20 | Brian Schwake Nashville SC | 24 | 24-26 | €150K | €600K | 0.25× |
Return-to-Peak Potential (RPP)
Recovery potential from current value to forecasted peak. Shows how much upside remains for players approaching their prime.
Understanding Return-to-Peak Potential (RPP)
San Diego FC's Duran Ferree at 19 years old has the highest Return-to-Peak Potential at +52%. That means Duran Ferree is projected to appreciate 52% as they reach their peak age in 7 years—representing significant upside before entering their prime.
In second is Philadelphia Union's Andrew Rick, who is 20 years old, with a +48% RPP (6 years to peak). Third is Adam Beaudry of Colorado Rapids, who is 20 years old with a +48% RPP (6 years to peak).
How RPP is calculated: RPP compares a player's current market value to their forecasted peak value, calculating the percentage appreciation potential. A 52% RPP means the player is expected to gain 52% value as they enter their prime—making them excellent growth investments.
Recovery Potential by Player
| Rank | Player | Age | Years to Peak | Current | Peak Forecast | RPP % |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Duran Ferree San Diego FC | 19 | 7 | €150K | €310K | +52% |
| #2 | Andrew Rick Philadelphia Union | 20 | 6 | €400K | €769K | +48% |
| #3 | Adam Beaudry Colorado Rapids | 20 | 6 | €200K | €384K | +48% |
| #4 | Jayden Hibbert Atlanta United FC | 21 | 5 | €500K | €894K | +44% |
| #5 | Chris Brady Chicago Fire FC | 22 | 4 | €2.5M | €4.2M | +40% |
| #6 | Thomas Gillier CF Montréal | 22 | 4 | €1.8M | €3.0M | +40% |
| #7 | Blake Gillingham Houston Dynamo FC | 23 | 3 | €150K | €232K | +35% |
| #8 | Rocco Ríos Novo Inter Miami CF | 23 | 3 | €600K | €927K | +35% |
| #9 | Javier Otero Orlando City SC | 23 | 3 | €150K | €232K | +35% |
| #10 | Jonathan Sirois CF Montréal | 24 | 2 | €1.0M | €1.4M | +30% |
| #11 | Isaac Boehmer Vancouver Whitecaps FC | 24 | 2 | €250K | €359K | +30% |
| #12 | Nicolas Hansen Colorado Rapids | 24 | 2 | €300K | €431K | +30% |
| #13 | Novak Mićović Los Angeles Galaxy | 24 | 2 | €600K | €862K | +30% |
| #14 | Hunter Sulte Portland Timbers | 24 | 2 | €150K | €216K | +30% |
| #15 | Brian Schwake Nashville SC | 24 | 2 | €150K | €216K | +30% |
| #16 | Roman Celentano FC Cincinnati | 25 | 1 | €2.5M | €3.3M | +25% |
| #17 | Tomás Romero New York City FC | 25 | 1 | €150K | €201K | +25% |
| #18 | John Pulskamp Sporting Kansas City | 25 | 1 | €600K | €802K | +25% |
| #19 | Patrick Schulte Columbus Crew | 25 | 1 | €3.5M | €4.7M | +25% |
| #20 | Michael Collodi FC Dallas | 25 | 1 | €400K | €535K | +25% |
Risk-Adjusted Upside (RAU)
Upside potential weighted against forecast uncertainty. Higher RAU = better risk-reward profile.
Understanding Risk-Adjusted Upside (RAU)
San Diego FC's Duran Ferree has the highest Risk-Adjusted Upside at 154.3. That means Duran Ferree has 40% upside potential with only 0% forecast uncertainty—representing excellent risk-reward for value appreciation.
In second is Philadelphia Union's Andrew Rick with a 118.5 RAU (28% upside, 0% uncertainty). Third is Adam Beaudry of Colorado Rapids with a 118.5 RAU (28% upside, 0% uncertainty).
How RAU is calculated: RAU divides upside potential by forecast uncertainty (RAU = Upside % ÷ Uncertainty %). A RAU of 154.3 means the upside is 154.3× greater than the uncertainty—making it a high-confidence growth opportunity. Target RAU ≥2.0 for balanced risk-reward.
Risk-Adjusted Upside by Player
| Rank | Player | Expected | Range | Upside % | RAU |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Duran Ferree San Diego FC | €209K | €190K-229K | +40% | 154.3 |
| #2 | Andrew Rick Philadelphia Union | €512K | €464K-559K | +28% | 118.5 |
| #3 | Adam Beaudry Colorado Rapids | €256K | €232K-279K | +28% | 118.5 |
| #4 | Jayden Hibbert Atlanta United FC | €617K | €561K-674K | +23% | 103.3 |
| #5 | Thomas Gillier CF Montréal | €2.1M | €2.0M-2.3M | +19% | 100.1 |
| #6 | Chris Brady Chicago Fire FC | €3.0M | €2.7M-3.2M | +19% | 100.1 |
| #7 | Blake Gillingham Houston Dynamo FC | €172K | €158K-186K | +15% | 79.9 |
| #8 | Rocco Ríos Novo Inter Miami CF | €688K | €633K-743K | +15% | 79.9 |
| #9 | Javier Otero Orlando City SC | €172K | €158K-186K | +15% | 79.9 |
| #10 | Jonathan Sirois CF Montréal | €1.1M | €1.0M-1.2M | +10% | 58.1 |
| #11 | Isaac Boehmer Vancouver Whitecaps FC | €276K | €254K-298K | +10% | 58.1 |
| #12 | Nicolas Hansen Colorado Rapids | €331K | €304K-357K | +10% | 58.1 |
| #13 | Novak Mićović Los Angeles Galaxy | €662K | €609K-714K | +10% | 58.1 |
| #14 | Hunter Sulte Portland Timbers | €165K | €152K-179K | +10% | 58.1 |
| #15 | Brian Schwake Nashville SC | €165K | €152K-179K | +10% | 58.1 |
| #16 | Brady Scott Los Angeles Galaxy | €134K | €123K-145K | +7% | 41.2 |
| #17 | AJ Marcucci New York Red Bulls | €268K | €246K-289K | +7% | 41.2 |
| #18 | Trey Muse Portland Timbers | €161K | €148K-173K | +7% | 41.2 |
| #19 | Luka Gavran Toronto FC | €161K | €148K-173K | +7% | 41.2 |
| #20 | Tomás Romero New York City FC | €159K | €146K-171K | +6% | 34.5 |
Roster Pressure Index (RPI)
Squad depth pressure based on Z-score distribution. Negative RPI = thin depth, positive = deep roster.
What This Shows
Z-Score explained: Measures how many standard deviations a player's strength is from the position average. Z-Score = 0 means average, +1.0 is one standard deviation above average, -1.0 is below average.
How to use: RPI < -1.0 indicates critical depth shortage. These positions need immediate reinforcement. RPI > +1.0 suggests strong depth, allowing selective, high-value additions only.
Current market: goalkeeper position shows strong depth (avg Z-score: 0.00). RPI: 0.00.
Position Depth Analysis
Highest Z-Scores
Lowest Z-Scores
Age-Share Concentration (ASC)
Identifies players capturing disproportionate value relative to age group representation. Positive ASC = value concentration.
Understanding Age-Share Concentration (ASC)
Philadelphia Union's Andrew Rick in the U21 age bracket has the highest Age-Share Concentration at +-3.2%. That means Andrew Rick captures 1.6% of total market value while representing only 4.8% of players in their age group—showing dominant elite status.
In second is San Diego FC's Duran Ferree with a +-3.2% ASC (1.6% value share vs 4.8% player share in U21 bracket). Third is Adam Beaudry of Colorado Rapids with a +-3.2% ASC (1.6% value vs 4.8% players in U21 bracket).
How ASC is calculated: ASC = (% of total value) - (% of total players) in age bracket. A +-3.2% ASC means the player captures -3.2% more market value than their numerical representation—indicating marquee status. ASC > +15% = elite dominance, ASC < -15% = potential value targets.
Value Concentration by Player
| Rank | Player | Age Bracket | Value Share | Player Share | ASC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Andrew Rick Philadelphia Union | U21 | 1.6% | 4.8% | -3.2% |
| #2 | Duran Ferree San Diego FC | U21 | 1.6% | 4.8% | -3.2% |
| #3 | Adam Beaudry Colorado Rapids | U21 | 1.6% | 4.8% | -3.2% |
| #4 | JT Marcinkowski Los Angeles Galaxy | 27-29 | 20.5% | 17.5% | +3.0% |
| #5 | Nicholas Hagen Columbus Crew | 27-29 | 20.5% | 17.5% | +3.0% |
| #6 | Maarten Paes FC Dallas | 27-29 | 20.5% | 17.5% | +3.0% |
| #7 | Mason Stajduhar Real Salt Lake City | 27-29 | 20.5% | 17.5% | +3.0% |
| #8 | James Pantemis Portland Timbers | 27-29 | 20.5% | 17.5% | +3.0% |
| #9 | Dayne St. Clair Inter Miami CF | 27-29 | 20.5% | 17.5% | +3.0% |
| #10 | Sébastian Breza CF Montréal | 27-29 | 20.5% | 17.5% | +3.0% |
| #11 | Matt Freese New York City FC | 27-29 | 20.5% | 17.5% | +3.0% |
| #12 | Alec Smir Minnesota United FC | 27-29 | 20.5% | 17.5% | +3.0% |
| #13 | Andrew Thomas Seattle Sounders FC | 27-29 | 20.5% | 17.5% | +3.0% |
| #14 | Luis Barraza Inter Miami CF | 27-29 | 20.5% | 17.5% | +3.0% |
| #15 | Jayden Hibbert Atlanta United FC | 21-23 | 11.9% | 9.5% | +2.4% |
| #16 | Blake Gillingham Houston Dynamo FC | 21-23 | 11.9% | 9.5% | +2.4% |
| #17 | Rocco Ríos Novo Inter Miami CF | 21-23 | 11.9% | 9.5% | +2.4% |
| #18 | Javier Otero Orlando City SC | 21-23 | 11.9% | 9.5% | +2.4% |
| #19 | Chris Brady Chicago Fire FC | 21-23 | 11.9% | 9.5% | +2.4% |
| #20 | Thomas Gillier CF Montréal | 21-23 | 11.9% | 9.5% | +2.4% |
Buy-Now vs Wait-List Map
Categorizes players by age position and upside potential to guide timing of acquisition.
What This Shows
How to use: "Buy Now - High Upside" = immediate priority targets. "Watch List" = monitor for 6-12 months. "Peak" = pay premium for proven performers. "Aging" = short-term depth only.
Current market: 6 immediate targets, 15 standard acquisitions, 0 watch-list prospects, 10 at peak.
BUY NOW - High Upside
WATCH LIST - High Upside
No players in this category
BUY NOW - Medium Upside
PEAK Players
Price vs Peer Z-Score
IQR-based pricing analysis relative to position peers. Identifies over/undervalued players vs market.
What This Shows
How to use: Z-score < -1.5 = significantly undervalued (potential bargain). Z-score > +1.5 = premium pricing (requires strong justification). Within ±1.0 = fair market value.
Current market: Position median is €300K. 0 undervalued, 7 premium.
Value Positioning vs Peers
| Player | Market Value | Position Median | Z-Score | Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Blake Gillingham Houston Dynamo FC | €150K | €300K | -0.27 | Fair Value |
Javier Otero Orlando City SC | €150K | €300K | -0.27 | Fair Value |
Earl Edwards Jr. San Jose Earthquakes | €125K | €300K | -0.21 | Fair Value |
Josh Cohen Chicago Fire FC | €125K | €300K | -0.21 | Fair Value |
Brady Scott Los Angeles Galaxy | €125K | €300K | -0.21 | Fair Value |
Duran Ferree San Diego FC | €150K | €300K | -0.20 | Fair Value |
Alec Smir Minnesota United FC | €150K | €300K | -0.19 | Fair Value |
Evan Louro FC Cincinnati | €150K | €300K | -0.18 | Fair Value |
Stefan Cleveland Sporting Kansas City | €150K | €300K | -0.18 | Fair Value |
Lucas Hoyos Atlanta United FC | €150K | €300K | -0.18 | Fair Value |
Stefan Frei Seattle Sounders FC | €150K | €300K | -0.18 | Fair Value |
Tomás Romero New York City FC | €150K | €300K | -0.18 | Fair Value |
Trey Muse Portland Timbers | €150K | €300K | -0.18 | Fair Value |
Hunter Sulte Portland Timbers | €150K | €300K | -0.18 | Fair Value |
Brian Schwake Nashville SC | €150K | €300K | -0.18 | Fair Value |
Luka Gavran Toronto FC | €150K | €300K | -0.18 | Fair Value |
Mason Stajduhar Real Salt Lake City | €175K | €300K | -0.17 | Fair Value |
JT Marcinkowski Los Angeles Galaxy | €200K | €300K | -0.15 | Fair Value |
Nicholas Hagen Columbus Crew | €200K | €300K | -0.15 | Fair Value |
Joe Willis Nashville SC | €175K | €300K | -0.15 | Fair Value |